RE: Re: P4 vs S4 - Pro's and con's
"The thing which makes me see red is when someone changes from the specified P4 dimensions, but still calls it P4. It's great that folks derive their own variant dimensions, but don't call it P4. Give it some other name of your own. If the check gauge is not 18.15mm min or the back to back is some preferred variant from the published standard, it is not P4. Call it P4-GTX or PBeansOnToast or whatever you like, but not P4.
Otherwise it is not fair to beginners trying to understand the basics, and spreads misinformation in the published record for decades to come.
regards,
Martin."
I just wanted to say from outside the cociety, that I heartily agree with the above sentiment. Major, well recognized and well understood standards such as 00 and HO frequently define both a gauge and scale, and there is an implied interchangeability if some variation which changes either or both, use the same name as part of their title. In my HO world, that's even been done deliberately, for the worst of reasons, solely to attract unsuspecting newcomers.
Andy
The importance of the name game
This section allows guests to comment or ask questions. Posts from guests require explicit approval (which generally takes a day or so), before they appear, so that we can prevent unwanted spam.
1 post
• Page 1 of 1
1 post
• Page 1 of 1
Jump to
- Area Groups
- Bristol
- Canadian Group
- Central London (CLAG)
- CHEAG
- Chilterns
- Cornish Riviera Area Group
- Craven Area Group
- Crewe (CAG)
- Cumbrian Region Area Group (CRAG)
- Marches Finescale Group
- Marshlink Finescale Area Group
- Norfolk & Suffolk Area Group
- North East Finescale Group
- North Norfolk
- Oxfordshire and West Berkshire AG (OWBAG)
- Vectis
- Virtual Group
- Starting in P4
- Jubilee Layout Challenge
- Challenge Layouts
- Jubilee Diorama Project
- Diorama Projects
- On My Workbench
- andrewnummelin
- Andrew Ullyott
- Andy W
- barrowroad
- best33
- Chris Mitton
- Colin Parks
- Craig Warton
- David B
- Dave K
- Dave Roome
- garethashenden
- Guy Rixon
- Hardwicke
- iak
- James Moorhouse
- Jeremy Good
- Jeremy Suter
- jim s-w
- jjnewitt
- John Donnelly
- jon price
- LesGros
- Lord Colnago
- Mark Tatlow
- MarkS
- Martin Kelly
- Paulhb
- Paul Townsend
- Paul Willis
- Peter Kloss
- Peter Meyer
- PeteT
- RobM
- Serjt-Dave
- timlewis
- Tim V
- Triode
- Weskie
- Will L
- Wizard of the Moor
- Standard Gauge Workbench
- Socially Distanced Challenge
- Trains: Model and Prototype
- Chassis and Suspensions
- Coaches and NPCS
- Couplings
- Diesel and Electric Locomotives
- Railmotors, Railcars and Multiple Units
- Steam Locomotives
- Track and Turnouts
- Tools and Techniques
- Lathe Work
- Painting and Weathering
- Other Workshop Practice
- Signals and Control Systems
- Control Concepts
- Colour Light Signals
- Semaphore Signals
- DCC
- Scenery and Structures
- Railway Buildings
- Other Buildings and Scenery
- Materials and Techniques
- Road Vehicles and Figures
- Layouts and Operations
- Baseboards and Carpentry
- Electrics
- Layout Location
- Operating in Practice
- Radio Control
- Exhibitions
- Virtual Scaleforum
- Layouts
- Demonstrations and Talks
- Society Stand and Stores
- Social
- Traders
- Scaleforum 2020 Website
- Local Show Publicity
- Product Information
- New Products
- Recommendations
- Where to Find?
- Guest Book
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: ClaudeBot and 1 guest