|
Chairmans
Cup.
|
Judges deliberations 1991.  and the competition stand 1995 
and again in 1999
 |
The Chairmans cup was awarded
at Scaleforum from 1978 to 2005. The models were judged in 6 classes with trophies for each class,
the Chairmans cup then going to the best in show. The class winners are listed here with the cup winner shown in red.
Note, classes 1 - 5 were introduced in 1979 and class 6 added in 1981. Class 6 entries were
awarded certificates but were not eligible for the cup. The classes were, 1 - Kit or
scratchbuilt locomotives, 2 - Coaching Stock, 3 - Freight Stock, 4 - Buildings, structures and lineside
items, 5 - Converted proprietary ready-to-run locomotives, 6 - Partly completed
models. |
| Year |
Class
|
Class Winner
|
Model
|
| 1978 |
n/a
|
John Palmer |
S&D 3F 0-6-0 |
| 1979 |
1 |
Bernard Baker |
LSWR Adams Radial |
| 2 |
Philip Millard |
5 LNWR carriages |
| 3 |
P A Jolly |
GWR fitted vans etc. |
| 4 |
Mike Jolly |
Winchester Chesil Station building and Warminster footbridge |
| 5 |
Ian Harrison |
GWR Autocoach from Mallard Kit |
| 1980 |
1 |
Tony Miles |
GNR(I) 'S' Class |
| 2 |
Tony Miles |
GNR(I) K16 Buffet Car |
| 3 |
Mike Jolly |
GWR cattle and brake vans |
| 4 |
John Hayes |
Bodmin Goods Shed |
| 5 |
Gerry Beale |
GWR Dean Goods - Mallard Kit |
| 1981 |
1 |
Bernard Baker |
LSWR X2 4-4-0 #593 |
| 2 |
B Fleming/P Tatlow |
LNER Gresley Coaches |
| 3 |
M D Goodwin |
Cambrian 2-plank wagons |
| 4 |
R S Petter |
LNWR Wooden Station building |
| 5 |
Ian Harrison |
GWR Horseboxes |
| 6 |
Tony Wilkins |
Trackwork from Addison Rd. |
| 1982 |
1 |
no entries |
|
| 2 |
Peter Tatlow |
HR Post Office van |
| 3 |
not awarded |
|
| 4 |
Adrian Gray |
GWR Signalbox and footbridge |
| 5 |
John Britton |
GWR Dean Goods |
| 6 |
Stan Glass |
LMS 4F |
| 1983 |
1, joint winner |
Bernard Baker |
LSWR 0-6-0T  |
| 1, joint winner |
Arthur Mold |
LMS Princess 4-6-2  |
| 1, highly commended |
Alan Clarke |
LMS Crab  |
| 2 |
Andrew Wiles |
GWR 1892 coaches  |
| 3 |
Paul Hollingsworth |
PO Wagons  |
| 4, winner |
Bill Hudson |
Cottages from 'Calver'  |
| 4, highly commended |
Bob Isgar |
Mineral hopper  |
| 5 |
no entries |
|
|
6
|
Tony Miles |
GNR(I) Q 4-4-0 
|
| 1984 |
1 |
Tony Miles |
GNR(I) Q 4-4-0  |
| 2 |
not awarded |
|
| 3 |
no entries |
|
| 4 |
Stephen Williams |
17th century almshouses |
| 5 |
not awarded |
|
| 6 |
Clive Croome |
Metropolitan coach |
| 1985 |
1 |
Alan Sibley |
GNR C12 4-4-2T  |
| 2 |
not awarded |
|
| 3, joint winner |
John Harper |
MGN Brake van |
| 3, joint winner |
Charles Trace |
MR and LBSCR wagons 
|
| 4 |
Mike Jolly |
Winchester Chesil station building  |
| 5 |
Philip Hall |
Mainline 57xx  |
| 6, joint winners |
Mike Jolly
Paul Garnworthy |
East Hill bridge
Barr end loco shed |
| 1986 |
1 |
Martin Finney |
GWR Stella 2-4-0 |
| 2 |
Alan Sibley |
MR 6 wheel full brake |
| 3 |
Charles Trace |
LBSC wagons |
| 4 |
Alan Sibley |
Pampisford Signal box |
| 5 |
Alan Sibley |
Hornby J52 |
| 6 |
Bob How |
Lydney Jcn station buildings |
| 1987 |
1 |
Malcolm Mitchell, winner |
GWR 45xx  |
| Highly Commended |
Martin Finney for Aberdare 2-6-0 and Andrew Wiles for GWR 850 class saddle tank. |
| Commended |
P. Taylor for terier tank 'Stepney' and Iain Rice for J39 0-6-0. |
| 2 |
Alan Sibley, winner |
S&D milk and fruit van |
| Highly Commended |
Alan Sibley for LT 1938 stock driving motor car and Martin Finey for GWR articulated coaches. |
| Commended |
Alan Sibley for Gresley Buffet car  
and Andrew Wiles for GWR 4 and 6 wheel coaches. |
| 3 |
Charles Trace |
Cowans Sheldon crane |
| 4 |
David Steele, winner |
elm trees |
| Commended |
Bob Howe for Lydney Junction station building. |
| 5 |
no entries |
|
| 6 |
Clive Croome |
PO wagons |
|
1988
|
1 |
Chris Pendlenton |
A1 4-6-2 |
| 2 |
no entries |
|
| 3 |
not awarded |
|
| 4 |
not awarded |
|
| 5 |
not awarded |
|
| 6 |
John Hayes |
LSWR O2 0-4-4Ts |
| 1989 to 1991 Chairman's Cup winner voted by
visitors, cup winner shown in red. |
|
1989
|
overall |
Philip Dalton |
Ledbury goods shed and yard |
| 1 |
Martin Finney |
GWR 4-4-0 'Pershore Plum' |
| 2 |
Graham Rayner |
GNR 45' Brake Composite |
| 3 |
Paul Severs |
SR 25T Bogie Brake Van |
| 4 |
Gerry Hall |
Street scene |
| 5 |
Bill Newton |
J50 0-6-0T |
| 6 |
Russ Elliott |
GWR fruit van. |
| 1990 |
1 |
Dave Bradwell
John Hayes (entered by Mike Sargent) |
NE Q6 0-8-0
GWR Bulldog |
| 2 |
Mike Clark |
LMS Coaches |
| 3 |
Charles Trace |
NER/GWR/SER Wagons |
| 4 |
Charles Trace |
Road vehicles |
| 5 |
Graham Rayner |
Hornby J52 |
| 6 |
not awarded |
|
| 1991 |
1 |
John Hayes |
GWR 0-6-0 |
| 2 |
Tony Osmond |
NLR Coaches |
| 3 |
Len Folkard |
LSWR brake vans  |
| 4 |
John Darch |
Bitton Station buildings |
| 5 |
not awarded |
|
| 6 |
Eric Pilgrim |
LSWR G6 0-6-0T |
|
1992
|
1 |
John Hayes |
GWR 2-8-0 |
| 2 |
Geoff Tiffany |
GNR Coaches and Horse box |
| 3 |
Len Folkard |
GWR and CR vehicles |
| 4 |
Robin Whittle |
Sheep Pasture engine shed |
| 5 |
not awarded |
|
| 6 |
Eric Pilgrim |
LSWR Adams radial |
| 1993 |
1 |
Alan Goodwillie |
A4 4-6-2 |
| 2 |
I Stockley |
GWR Passenger brake |
| 3 |
Steve Hall |
LMS Mineral wagons |
| 4 |
John Darch |
Brinkley goods shed |
| 5 |
no entries |
|
| 6 |
not awarded |
|
| 1994 |
1 |
Paul Moore, winner |
Stockton & Darlington 101 class  |
|
Highly commended |
Bernard Baker for Schools  |
| 2 |
Steve Banks |
GWR dia C54a Collett corridor 3rd. |
| 3 |
Peter Swift
Len Folkard |
LSWR wagons
MR wagons |
| 4 |
Lynden Emery |
Ringwood station footbridge  |
| 5 |
not awarded |
|
| 6 |
not awarded |
|
|
1995
|
1 |
Phil Taylor |
LBSCR B4  |
| 2 |
Derek Dwyer |
GER Coaches and van |
| 3 |
Len Folkard |
LSWR Machinery truck |
| 4 |
Barry Luck |
Arun barge |
| 5 |
Commended |
Detailed Lima 37 by ###  |
| 6 |
not awarded |
|
|
1996
|
1 |
Steve Lee |
Peckett R2 0-4-0ST  |
| 2 |
Steve Banks |
LNER Restaurant car  |
| 3 |
Tim Shackleton |
contractors' wagons |
| 4 |
not awarded |
|
| 5 |
not awarded |
|
| 6 |
Geoff Tiffany
very highly commended |
GNR F2 0-4-2  |
|
1997
|
1 |
John Hayes |
A3 4-6-2  |
| 2 |
Ian Stockley |
GWR Brake and newspaper vans  |
| 3 |
Peter Heald |
NS twin wagons  |
| 4 |
Charles Davidson |
Bedlay colliery furnace  |
| 5 |
not awarded |
|
| 6 |
not awarded |
|
|
1998
|
1 |
Alex Duckworth |
Garratt - William Francis  |
| 2 |
Rodney Cooper |
GWR D124 Corridor Bk 3rd  |
| 3 |
not awarded |
|
| 4 |
Philip Dalton |
Ledbury footbridge  |
| 5 |
no entries |
|
| 6 |
no entries |
|
|
1999
|
1 |
Graham Seed |
45xx  |
| 2 |
Alan Robinson |
GWR dia. E128 coach |
| 3 |
John Hayes |
rake of coal wagons |
| 4 |
no entries |
|
| 5 |
not awarded |
|
| 6 |
not awarded |
|
|
2000
|
1 |
Chris Pendlenton |
A2/3 4-6-2  |
| 2 |
Keith Bradbury |
4 LMS coaches  |
| 3 |
Alan Coppin |
oil tank wagons  |
| 4 |
Peter Wilson |
footbridge for Green St.  |
| 5 |
no entries |
|
| 6 |
no entries |
|
|
2001
|
1 |
Ian Harrison |
GWR 57xx  |
| 2 |
Alan Robinson |
GWR dia. K40 Full brake  |
| 3 |
not awarded |
|
| 4 |
Jim Summers |
Killin Junction Signal Box  |
| 5 |
Paul Moore |
Class 25  |
| 6 |
Peter Sutherland |
GWR 4-wheel coaches  |
|
2002
|
1 |
David Lane |
SR Q1 0-6-0  |
| 2 |
Simon De Souza |
Highland Railway Carriage Trucks |
| 3 |
no entries |
|
| 4 |
Philip Dalton |
Ledbury Station, GWR |
| 5 |
Simon Stevens |
Bachmann Type 2, 24036 |
| 6 |
Peter Fitzwater |
GWR 53xx |
|
2003
|
1 |
John Lingwood |
BR Caprotti Black 5,
4-6-0 |
| 2 |
Peter Sutherland |
GWR 4-wheel
coach |
| 3 |
Peter Sutherland |
GWR Engineers' van |
| 4 |
Graham Rayner |
GNR Somersault signal |
| 5 |
David Lane |
Samhongsa ex GWR 97xx
0-6-0PT |
| 6 |
no entries |
|
|
2004
|
1 |
Morgan Gilbert |
Ex MR Johnson 0-4-4T No
58071 |
| 2 |
not awarded |
|
| 3 |
Ray
Nolton |
Caledonian
Railway Tank Wagon |
| 4 |
Philip Dalton |
Goods Shed at Ledbury |
| 5 |
Stefan Lewis |
Ex LMS 2-6-2T No 41202 |
| 6 |
no entries |
|
| 2005 |
1 |
Bernard Baker |
Schools
Class locomotive no. 922
|
| 2 |
Bernard
Baker
|
Pullman
car "Iolanthe".
|
| 3 |
Keith
Bradbury
|
A
rake of three 1960's British Railways brake vans
|
| 4 |
Michael
Godfrey
|
Trackwork,
built from photographs of a British prototype, incorporating 'C' type
switches and fitted with stretcher bars, etc.
|
| 5 |
James
Wells
|
British
Railways class 37 diesel locomotive
|
| 6 |
no entries |
|
